Picture
Have you ever tried making homemade mustard?  Once you do, you will never buy it at the store again.  It just doesn’t compare.  I love spicy mustard and I wanted to share this recipe I developed.  I've been making it for my family and friends.

Basic mustard is nothing more than mustard powder and water.  What gives it a “bite” is the chemical reaction that happens when you mix the mustard seed/powder with a “cold” liquid (if you like mild mustard, then use a warm liquid).  The trick is to mix in an acid, like vinegar, after the chemicals react, to lock in that fiery flavor.   

My recipe is a very simple process using mustard seed, mustard powder, a cold liquid, vinegar, and spices.  For the cold liquid, I use stout beer, which adds a delicious malty flavor.  I use brown and yellow mustard seeds, and keep mustard powder on hand in case I want to thicken it.  Although, if it’s too thick for your taste, you just can add more vinegar.

This mustard will not deteriorate since it’s mixed with vinegar and salt.  Refrigeration is not needed, but it you want to keep that fiery flavor, I would recommend it.  

TIP:  Mustard seed is extremely expensive at the grocery store.  I found a source for mustard seed/powder that comes in a set called “Colonel Mustard’s Favorite Set” at My Spice Sage.  It includes one each - 16 oz. Mustard Powder, Yellow Mustard Seed, Brown Mustard Seed, and Brown Crushed Mustard Seed, for $26.00.  This set goes a long way in making mustard.  Your order will also include a free spice sample of their choice, a free sample of your choice, and free shipping.  I am not an affiliate of My Spice Sage.

I hope you try this recipe and let me know how you like it. 

Miss Lady Bug’s Dixie Mustard

Ingredients:

1/2 cup Ground Mustard  
1/2 cup Mustard Seeds Whole (Brown) 
1/2 Mustard Seeds Whole (Yellow) 
1 1/2 cups (or 12 oz.) Stout Beer (or water) 
1 1/2 cups Red Wine Vinegar (or cider vinegar) 
2 tablespoons Brown Sugar 
1 teaspoon Granulated Garlic 
1 teaspoon Kosher Salt 
1 teaspoon Black Pepper Freshly Ground 
1/4 teaspoon Ground Ginger 
1/4 teaspoon Turmeric 
1/4 teaspoon Cinnamon

Directions:

1. Whisk together ground mustard, mustard seeds and COLD beer in a bowl and set it aside for ten minutes (creates a chemical reaction).
2. Add vinegar (locks in fiery flavor), sugar, and spices.  Whisk.  
3. Let sit for 24-48 hrs, covered.
4. Blend in food processor (or blender to break up softened seeds). 
5. Adjust thickness with mustard powder if desired.
6. Add to sterilized jars. 
7. Refrigerate to preserve spiciness.

I double this recipe to yield approximately four pints.  Delicious!  Enjoy.
By Miss Lady Bug
 


Comments

Rainee
07/11/2012 12:13am

I never thought of making mustard before but it sounds pretty good. You're right about the mustard seed being expensive, so is it worth the cost? Very interesting though.

Reply
MLBug
07/11/2012 2:10pm

Yes it is worth it!!!! Just buy your mustard seed in bulk; it doesn't cost much that way and it makes tons of delicious mustard.

Reply
Goofy
08/24/2012 8:33am

I love this stuff! It's hot & spicy just like Miss Lady Bug! ;^)

Reply
Deborah
09/30/2012 2:34pm

Can you can this recipe in a waterbath?

Reply
MLBug
09/30/2012 3:39pm

There is no need to process this mustard recipe as it will not deteriorate. Mustard plants have anti-microbial properties to begin with, and the vinegar and salt preserve it. If you add other ingredients (i.e. nut or seed based), then it will require refrigeration to keep from going rancid. This recipe will not go bad but may dry out over time. If this happens, just add more vinegar. Also, it will lose some of that fabulous spiciness when cooked (or left in the pantry for long periods of time). I've made a lot of this mustard and I keep it refrigerated because I like it hot!

stacy
11/11/2012 4:57pm

Question. In your directions you do not mention when you add the other ingredients...garlic, brown sugar, ginger, turmeric, and cinnamon. At what step should these be added? Thank you, I just bought all of the mustard seed and I can't wait to try making this recipe.

Reply
MLBug
11/12/2012 1:00pm

Stacy, see step #2 to add vinegar, sugar, and all the spices. Let me know how you like it... I think it is so delicious!

Reply
Mike
01/26/2013 3:43pm

This is great! I've wanted to make mustard for a while. Question... When I let it sit covered should it be refrigerated or left at room temp?

Thanks!

Reply
MLBug
01/26/2013 5:17pm

It is fine left at room temperature, even after you bottle it, although, over time it will become more mild. I store mine in the fridge to keep it spicy. Let me know how you like it Mike!

Reply
Mike
01/26/2013 5:24pm

Great. Thanks!!

Nancy
01/29/2013 2:05pm

Sounds delish, but due to stomach problems I have to have the mild. When you say warm liquid, do you still use a beer that is room temp or some other liquid?

Reply
MLBug
01/29/2013 3:32pm

Yes use the stout beer at room temp (to get that malty flavor). Let me know how it goes. Thanks Nancy!

Reply
02/27/2013 8:13am

I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. I am quite sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!

Reply
MLBug
02/28/2013 6:00pm

I appreciate it... my site is certainly kid friendly. I hope you will try homemade mustard. Thanks!

Reply
reid
03/11/2013 4:42pm

can i mix in diced hot peppers

Reply
MLBug
03/11/2013 5:59pm

Yes you can but the mustard will need to be refrigerated and consumed within a few weeks. Thanks for stopping by!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply